Lightning safety outdoors: U.S. and Japanese guidance compared

The National Weather Service (NWS) says lightning strikes the United States about 25 million times a year and kills about 20 people in the U.S. each year, with hundreds more severely injured. Its message is short: When Thunder Roars, Go Indoors. If you can hear thunder, lightning is close enough to strike you, and there is no safe place outside when thunderstorms are in the area.

What is safe shelter

NWS defines it as a substantial building with electricity or plumbing, or an enclosed, metal-topped vehicle with the windows up. A tent, picnic shelter, or open-sided pavilion is not on that list. Stay in safe shelter at least 30 minutes after you hear the last sound of thunder.

Inside isn't automatically safe

NWS says a house is a safe place during a thunderstorm as long as you avoid anything that conducts electricity:

  • Stay off corded phones, computers and other electrical equipment that put you in direct contact with electricity.
  • Avoid plumbing, including sinks, baths and faucets.
  • Stay away from windows and doors, and stay off porches.
  • Don't lie on concrete floors or lean against concrete walls.

If you're caught outside

NWS stresses that nothing outside is safe, but these last-resort steps may reduce risk:

  • Get off elevated areas such as hills, mountain ridges and peaks.
  • Never lie flat on the ground; never shelter under an isolated tree or a cliff or rocky overhang.
  • Get out of and away from ponds, lakes and other water.
  • Stay away from things that conduct electricity, like barbed-wire fences, power lines and windmills.

Myths that get people hurt (NWS)

MythFact
Crouching makes you safeCrouching doesn't make you any safer outdoors. Get to a substantial building or hard-topped vehicle
A tree keeps you dry and safeBeing underneath a tree is the second leading cause of lightning casualties
No rain overhead means no danger"Bolts from the blue" can strike 10 to 15 miles from the storm
Lightning never strikes the same place twiceIt often does; the Empire State Building is hit an average of 23 times a year
Metal attracts lightningHeight, pointy shape and isolation decide where it strikes; metal makes no difference. Don't waste time removing it
A victim is still electrifiedThe body doesn't store electricity. It's safe to touch a lightning victim and give first aid, including CPR
You can finish the game firstMany casualties happen because people don't seek shelter soon enough

How Japan's guidance compares

TopicNWS (U.S.)Japan Meteorological Agency
Safe placesSubstantial building; enclosed, metal-topped vehicleReinforced-concrete buildings, cars (not convertibles), buses, trains; wooden houses are basically safe too, and safer still if you keep 1 m from electrical appliances, ceilings and walls
Dangerous placesElevated areas, water, open areasSports fields, golf courses, outdoor pools, levees, beaches, the sea; mountain peaks and ridges
TreesNever shelter under an isolated treeStay at least 2 m from every part of a tall tree (trunk, branches, leaves). Most deaths sheltering under trees come from "side flash", lightning jumping from the tree to a person
No shelter nearbyLast-resort tips aboveA "protected zone": at least 4 m from a tall object such as a utility pole, within the area where you look up at its top at 45 degrees or more; keep low and don't hold things above your body
When to move againAt least 30 minutes after the last thunderMove to safe shelter after lightning activity has stopped for 20 minutes or more

JMA's page credits its guidance to the Society of Atmospheric Electricity of Japan's safety Q&A. The two agencies agree on the essentials. Where they differ, we'd follow the more cautious figure: wait 30 minutes.

Planning a trip around storms (our suggestions)

  • Check the forecast for thunderstorms before you go, and plan to be off peaks and ridges by early afternoon on storm-prone days.
  • At camp, know where the nearest building or your car is, and move there at the first thunder.
  • If someone is struck, call 911 and start CPR if needed; it is safe to touch them. See Finding a CPR and first aid class.

Everyday

Check the forecast for thunderstorms before a hike or camp, and note where the nearest building or car is.

When it counts

At the first thunder you move to real shelter, instead of waiting under a tree.

Sources and when we checked them

Spotted a mistake? Tell us through the contact form ("Report a mistake"). We check it, fix it, and log the change in Updates.